After four weeks of voting, the final results are in. Gettysburg Connection readers have chosen Adams County’s top pizzerias in the first-ever Winter Readers’ Pizza Poll.
A total of 406 votes were cast across 12 participating pizzerias, with readers rating their favorite local spots throughout the winter. The final rankings were determined by computing the average star ratings submitted through the poll.
Like the athletes competing on the world stage at the Winter Olympics, Adams County’s favorite pizzerias earned their places on the podium through strong performances, dedicated supporters, and a little hometown pride.
Here are the medal winners:
🥇 Gold Medal: Antica Napoli
39 N. Washington St., Gettysburg
4.44 out of 5 stars from 72 raters
Antica Napoli earned the highest overall rating in the poll, securing the gold medal and local bragging rights for 2026.
🥈 Silver Medal: Tommy’s Pizza
105 Steinwehr Ave., Gettysburg
4.27 out of 5 stars from 95 raters
Tommy’s Pizza received the largest number of ratings in the contest and finished with a strong overall score, earning the silver medal.
🥉 Bronze Medal: Clementina’s Pizzeria & Ristorante
4.17 out of 5 stars from 23 raters
Clementina’s rounds out the podium with a solid rating and a place among the county’s top-ranked pizzerias.
Two additional pizzerias finished just off the podium:
• Deliso Pizza — 4.13 stars from 45 raters
• La Bella Italia — 4.11 stars from 54 raters
View the complete results here.
We are deeply grateful to everyone who took the time to participate. Thank you to every reader who voted, shared the poll, encouraged friends to weigh in, and supported local businesses by joining the conversation. Community participation is what makes projects like this possible, and your enthusiasm turned a simple winter idea into a lively countywide event. Gettysburg Connection exists because of engaged readers, and we sincerely appreciate the time, energy, and hometown pride you brought to this poll.
The close scores highlight the depth of Adams County’s local pizza scene and the enthusiasm readers brought to the winter poll.
Because winter may be long, opinions may be strong — but pizza always brings people together. 🍕