Totem Pole Playhouse in Fayetteville is turning 75—and it’s going to be one unforgettable summer. With a lineup packed with musicals, comedy, variety, and a brand-new Tuesday night series, Pennsylvania’s premier summer theatre is celebrating its Diamond Anniversary in sparkling style.
“We’ve packed this season with blockbuster titles, beloved artists, and big surprises. From jukebox musicals to magical Tuesdays, it’s going to be a party all summer long—and we want everyone to come celebrate with us!” said Producing Artistic Director Ryan B. Gibbs.
The 75th season opens May 30 with The Marvelous Wonderettes (only 12 performances, May 30–June 8), the story of four best friends who sing at their high school prom (1958) and reunite a decade (1968) later to perform again. This jukebox joyride is a tribute to anyone who still keeps in touch with their best friends from high school—and it’s the perfect throwback to launch a season about memories and music.
From there, the tempo picks up with 9 to 5: The Musical (20 performances, June 20–July 6), featuring music and lyrics by Dolly Parton. With strong women, big laughs, and even bigger hair, this workplace revenge fantasy is set to break Totem Pole’s group sales record—so don’t wait too long to grab those tickets!
Up next is Alfred Hitchcock’s The 39 Steps (only 12 performances, July 18–July 27), a fast-paced comedy murder mystery where four actors take on performing over 50 characters in a nonstop whirlwind of espionage, slapstick, and surprises.
Beautiful: The Carole King Musical (20 performances, August 8–24) tells the inspiring life story of the groundbreaking singer-songwriter behind the soundtrack of a generation. Filled with chart-topping hits and woven together like a musical “tapestry”, this Broadway smash is a heartfelt celebration of creativity, resilience, and finding your own voice.
Closing the mainstage season is Diamond: The Neil Diamond Tribute starring Scott Moreau (only 8 performances, August 27–August 31). With all the hits you know by heart—and happening on a literal hot August night—this show is the ultimate capstone to our Diamond Anniversary. Coincidence? We don’t think so.