Gettysburg Connection is pleased to share the opinions of Adams County residents. This article is an opinion piece (op-ed) that represents the opinion and analysis of the writer. The views expressed do not necessarily reflect the opinions or views of Gettysburg Connection or its supporters. We'd love to share your thoughts. Please leave a comment below or email us:

A “Gut Check” on Climate?

Climate change denial comes in many flavors these days and Bob Stilwell’s opinion piece, “Climate Change Gut Check,” published in the Gettysburg Times on Thursday, December 19 draws on almost all of them. If you care about environmental issues and haven’t seen the article, you really need to check it out. And respond with a letter to the editor if you have time.

Back in the bad old days, climate change denialists simply denied that the climate was changing at all. It was a hoax, perpetrated by greedy climate scientists thirsty for grant money and clean energy investors hungry for profits. As temperatures have risen and unprecedented weather events have accumulated, however, the narrative has had to change and denialists have had to adapt. Wild fires, hurricanes, flooding, droughts, heat waves, rising seas—they have become pretty hard to ignore.

community voices 300

Yes, the denialists now say, and Bob Stilwell says too, temperatures are rising and the global climate is changing but…  it has nothing to do with human activities such as the burning of fossil fuels. This despite that fact that we have known at least since the days of the Swedish scientist Svante Arrhenius in the late nineteenth century that carbon dioxide traps heat and that the burning of massive amounts of fossil fuels—coal in those early days—would raise earth’s temperature significantly. 

But “Earth’s climate has been changing for millions of years,” the denialists and Stilwell counter. Humanity, he says “needs to shed the arrogant notion that we can change what has been happening” for so many years. He neglects to mention, of course, that back in the good old days when carbon dioxide levels were even higher than today, temperatures (and sea levels) were much higher, too. Dinosaurs might have walked the earth, but humans did not.

The truth is we have occupied a relatively stable climate “sweet spot” through the entirety of human evolution, a sweet spot that we have now put at risk.  We need a functioning biosphere.  We need a stable climate to support human civilization. And we have damaged both, not only with the burning of fossil fuels but with the destruction of forests and grasslands, and the pollution of the world’s air and oceans.

Toward the end of his article, Stilwell gives the game away with his pitch for burning more fossil fuels.  In the end, isn’t that what denialism is all about: making excuses for continuing to burn—or turn into throwaway plastics—more and more fossil fuels? Fossil fuels that now must stay in the ground if we are going to deal effectively with rising temperatures.

Like most denialists Stilwell assumes that we have an either-or choice to make: either fossil fuels, a robust economy and jobs or cleaner energy, a healthy biosphere, and a stable climate. But that’s a false choice. The truth is every environmental solution must also be an economic solution and every economic solution must also be grounded in respect for the environment. 

We have the tools we need to address the climate crisis and other environmental problems.  Now it’s time to face these problems squarely and get to work fixing them.

+ posts

Will Lane, a founding member of Green Gettysburg and the Green Gettysburg Book Club, is a Lecturer in English and Affiliated Faculty Member with Environmental Studies at Gettysburg College.

Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Debby Luquette
Debby Luquette
1 year ago

When I was teaching at Howard Community College, the humor displayed on one’s office door was a welcome way to lighten someone’s time meandering the hallways. One of my favorites pictured a lecturer on stage, in front of a blackboard. The left side showed fossil fuels and some associated problems; the right showed renewable energy and some associated benefits. A person in the audience is standing and yelling, “What if we create a better world and it’s all a hoax.” While fossil fuels do supply plenty of work – cleaning up after disasters, medical interventions for respiratory and cardiac illnesses… Read more »

Beth Farnham
Beth Farnham
1 year ago

Many renowned institutions of higher learning dedicate courses, degrees, and whole buildings to climate change study and solutions. Virginia Tech is one, for example –

If one happens to know where climate change denialists have graduated from, one might consider redirecting them to their alma maters.

1 year ago

Climate change lost me back in the 70’s when we were being told that temperatures were dropping and that we were entering and ice age. Seems to me that there are people out there that will say anything and twist any facts so that the money will pour their way.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x